Anna Cutler, CLA Research Associate, examines recent research from Professor Pat Thomson to consider how we might start to turn back the tide on the erosion of the Arts in schools – and identifies the crucial role of school leadership in revitalising Arts education.
Tide’s out
The CLA’s 2026 Report Card offers a striking image of the tide having gone out on Arts education in schools, leaving only occasional rockpools of excellence intact. We applaud the schools that have created and sustained these rockpools, while recognising that, for many others, the ebbing tide has left little but sand behind.
In schools where there are few, if any, specialist teachers in the Arts, or where the Arts have struggled to find a place, the question is where to begin. After so many years of the Arts sitting at the margins, and with limited experience in the subjects, how can school leaders start to turn the tide? It won’t happen overnight, but it can, and most certainly needs to begin now, and with renewed commitment, if we genuinely believe that every child is entitled to arts education.
Where to start?
An obvious starting point might include professional development in the Arts for staff to gain new skills, knowledge and capacity. Some schools already do this; leaders also mentor one another, sharing ideas and resources. Others appoint a specialist member of staff to lead and develop an Arts programme or bring in external cultural organisations to support its growth. All of these can be valuable, and may be necessary, for the arts to thrive again. But are they enough? Is there something else happening in the schools that experience success?
In Generative conditions for shared leadership in Arts-rich schools (2026), Pat Thomson and Christine Hall identify the ‘something else’ as school leadership and culture. They summarise Arts-rich schools as those that treat the Arts as a core entitlement for every child. These schools provide regular, high-quality teaching across a wide range of Arts subjects with specialist teachers. These are schools that celebrate achievement and have partnerships with external cultural organisations. All contribute to a school culture in which the Arts are central to identity and everyday practice.
In this article, Thomson and Hall lay out the conditions that enable the Arts to thrive, illustrating how existing schools – the ones with the rockpools – have cultivated them. Drawn from Researching the Arts in Primary Schools data (Thomson, Hall, C, Maloy, 2021-23), they analyse what works and why, using the framework of school-as-design to identify eight consistently observed conditions.
The framework
What might be said to be most significant about this framework is that it describes the ongoing creation of a culture accessible to any school “that commits to cultivating it” (p.14). Its starting point is not an entirely new set of resources, buildings, or the casting aside of everything before, but the redesign of ‘familiar elements’ already in place.
To explain this approach, the authors draw on Thomson and Blackmore (2006), reminding us:
“They argued that schools are not invented from scratch but continuously remade through the combination and recombination of familiar elements: curriculum time, staffing, physical space, partnership arrangements and assessment practices.”
In this view, no school is “fixed”; indeed, as the authors note, in relation to ecological approaches, “schools are better understood as living systems than as machines” and that “formal leadership in such systems is less about directing action than about cultivating conditions.”
This shifts attention from individual leaders to the relationships across a school. As the article explains (p.2):
“collective generative capacity resides not in individuals or structural arrangements alone but in the quality of relationships, norms and practises across the whole organisation.”
Reshaping what’s possible for the Arts therefore starts with the premise that change is not just possible, but always in potential: that schools are not unchangeable structures but evolving systems; leaders can remake and recombine the “familiar elements,” cultivating the conditions by design.
Eight Conditions
What, then, are the conditions that support this culture? Thomson and Hall name eight interconnected conditions that together articulate a form of shared leadership: mutual trust across hierarchical levels; expertise circulates freely; agency is endemic; collaboration is chosen, not mandated; structures enable rather than control; shared conviction about purpose; learning is continuous and universal; and contribution is visible and celebrated.
The authors discuss these in detail and present them diagrammatically, demonstrating how they function as a wider school ecology, dependent on one another, rather than operating as separate initiatives. They also offer seven recurring processes to sustain the conditions that provide shared sensemaking and external recognition of the school’s Arts identity. I would argue that they also support and help shape a sense of belonging, from governors to staff, to children and their extended communities.
The framework in practice
A separate research project with school leaders found almost identical conditions and processes, exemplifying the framework in practice. Creative Ingredients: Exploring the conditions that enable creativity to thrive in schools (2024), emerged from the Royal Ballet and Opera’s Leaders for Impact programme. It examines the core “ingredients,” as defined by school leaders, that allow for the Arts and creativity to flourish. These echo the eight conditions outlined above and articulate the need for shared vision and values, collaborative leadership, a focus on school culture, creative pedagogies and environments, partnerships and networks. Trust, working across “levels” and doing so organically, rather than through prescription, all feature in the research.
Creative Ingredients II (2025) dug further into the initial findings, with concrete examples given by school leaders that highlight their day-to-day processes and decision-making. Leaders share stories they have written about Arts and creative activity in their schools. These accounts use similar language to describe schools as living systems with students also actively contributing to their development:
“We heard about schools in which creativity defines the culture of learning, where students are encouraged to take an active role in making and remaking their own learning environments and about how this atmosphere spreads across the school.”
A booklet brings together the school leaders’ reflections, offering more and very profound examples of how school culture can be cultivated (see here or see all links below).
Local tides
Of course, there are endless examples of this sort to be found across schools and cultural organisations in the UK, as well as in academia, that provide evidence and reassurance. The examples used here were chosen to indicate that school-as-design turns Arts development in school from a question of adding new provision or expensive materials into the active process of redesigning school culture. It implies leadership that is inclusive, and that nurtures a sense of profound belonging – available to all.
Turning the tide for Arts education will not be achieved through a single initiative, isolated project or occasional cultural visit. The rockpools that remain demonstrate what is possible, but the task now is to connect them, deepen them and help new ones form. By reshaping school cultures and remaking what is already available, leaders can begin to turn their local tides. The goal is not simply to restore what has been lost, but to design schools in which the Arts are visible, valued and woven into the lives of every child.
References
Thomson, P., & Hall, C. (2026). Generative conditions for shared leadership in arts-rich schools. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/17411432261438948 (accessed 27/10/ 2026)
Thomson, P., Hall, C., & Maloy, L. (2025). Researching the arts in primary schools [Project Report]. University of Nottingham / Freelands Foundation. https://artsprimary.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/raps-final-feb-2025 (accessed27/10/2026)
Thomson, P., Blackmore, J. (2006). Beyond the power of one: redesigning the work of school principals. J Educ Change 7, 161–177 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10833-006-0003-6 (accessed 27/10/2026)
Cutler, A., Davies. S.B., Nicolson, H. (2024) Creative Ingredients: Exploring the conditions that enable creativity to thrive in schools, Royal Ballet and Opera. https://www.rbo.org.uk/schools/resource/creative-ingredients (accessed 27/10/2026)
Cutler, A., Davies. S.B., Nicolson, H. (2025) Creative Ingredients II: Stories of Leadership and Creativity and Leadership, Royal Ballet and Opera. https://www.rbo.org.uk/schools/resource/creative-ingredients (accessed 27/10/2026)





1 thought on “School Leadership: Turning the Tide of Arts Education”
Comments are closed.